Gifts as Unique as the People Receiving Them

Some people are easy to shop for. Others need a little creativity—and that is where we come in.

At The Milled Olive, we create custom gifts filled with products chosen specifically for the person, occasion and budget. From premium olive oils and balsamic vinegars to gourmet foods, kitchen favorites, home accents and Idaho specialties, every gift is thoughtfully assembled and beautifully presented.

Start With a Little Inspiration

You do not have to know exactly what belongs in the gift. Simply tell us about the recipient, and our team will help bring your ideas to life.

We can create a gift around a favorite flavor, hobby, color, decorating style, special occasion, premium brand, Idaho theme or price range. You can even leave the decisions to us and let our team surprise you.

Let's create something memorable

Choose How You Would Like to Create

There is no wrong way to begin. Choose the level of guidance that works best for you.

  • Let Us Surprise You

    Tell us about the recipient, occasion and budget. Our team will select a thoughtful combination and contact you to review the details.

  • Give Us a Starting Point

    Choose a theme, favorite flavor, preferred colors or a few must-have products. We will complete the gift around your ideas.

  • Select the Products Yourself

    Visit The Milled Olive and personally select the products you would like included. We will help arrange and finish the presentation.

So Many Ways to Make It Personal

Depending on the recipient, occasion, budget and current availability, your custom gift may include:

• Olive oils and balsamic vinegars
• Gourmet foods, sauces, pastas and seasonings
• Baking mixes, sweets and specialty treats
• Loose-leaf teas and beverage accessories
• Kitchen tools and entertaining essentials
• Cookware, bakeware and serving pieces
• Home décor and seasonal accents
• Idaho and huckleberry favorites
• Products from premium brands carried in our store
• A personal message from you

Have something particular in mind? Include it in your request and we will do our best to bring your idea to life.

Perfect for Life’s Big Moments—and the Little Ones Too

Birthdays • Weddings • Anniversaries • Engagements • Housewarmings • Hostess Gifts • Thank-You Gifts • New Babies • Sympathy Gifts • Graduations • Retirements • Holidays • Employee Recognition • Client Appreciation • Realtor and Builder Closing Gifts • Just-Because Surprises

Gifting for Your Business

Business gifts should feel personal—not mass-produced.

The Milled Olive works with local businesses, realtors, builders and organizations to create gifts for clients, employees, homeowners, special events and holiday celebrations. We can coordinate multiple gifts around your desired theme, price range and presentation.

Whether you need one important client gift or a larger coordinated order, we will help you create something that reflects both your business and your appreciation.

Begin a Business Gift Request

Where Food Meets Fun—and Gifting Gets Personal

The Milled Olive is locally owned and operated in Star by husband-and-wife team Dan and Angie McGetrick. Our store was created from a shared love of food, cooking, entertaining, decorating and helping people discover something unexpected.

That same creativity goes into every gift we prepare. We do not believe custom gifting should feel generic. It should feel personal, joyful and chosen with care.

Tell Us What You’re Imagining

Share as much—or as little—as you know. Our team will contact you to discuss ideas, availability, pricing and timing before your gift is completed.

For rush requests, call us at 208-205-9030.

Submitting this form does not require payment and does not place a final order.

Custom Gift Questions

How far in advance should I submit my request?

We recommend submitting your request at least two business days before your desired pickup date. Larger business and holiday orders may require additional time. For a rush request, call us at 208-205-9030.

Is there a minimum purchase?

We can create thoughtful gifts at many price points. Tell us your preferred budget in the request form and we will explain the available options.

Will I approve the gift before it is completed?

Yes. A member of our team will contact you to confirm the theme, products, pricing and pickup details before your gift is finalized.

Can you create several matching gifts?

Yes. We can create coordinated gifts for clients, employees, real estate closings, events and holidays. Preparation time and product availability will depend on the quantity requested.

Can you accommodate allergies or dietary restrictions?

Please include any dietary restrictions or allergies in the request form. We will consider that information when recommending products, but we cannot guarantee an allergen-free environment.

Can I request particular products or brands?

Yes. Tell us what you have in mind and we will check availability. If something is unavailable, we can recommend an appropriate alternative.

Where do I pick up my gift?

Completed gifts can be picked up at The Milled Olive in Star, Idaho. We will confirm the pickup date and details when your gift is approved.

Do you deliver or ship custom gifts?

Please contact Dan or Angie at 208-205-9030 to discuss this option.

Let’s Make Their Gift Unforgettable

From delicious and practical to beautiful and unexpected, we will help you give something they will be excited to open.

Start My Custom Gift